Outsourcing Green Energy: What's Up Taiwan – News at 14:00, October 16, 2024 | T

Started by indirect, Oct 20, 2024, 06:48 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


tagninopso

Here's a summary of what the October 16, 2024 coverage ("Outsourcing Green Energy, What's Up Taiwan – News at 14:00") was about, plus some of the debate, challenges, and implications. If you want, I can also pull up video clips or transcripts.

🇹🇼 What's Going On: Taiwan Considers Outsourcing Green Energy

Proposal by the Economics Minister

Taiwan's Economic Affairs Minister Kuo Jyh-huei floated an idea: build renewable (green) energy power plants in nearby countries—specifically Japan and the Philippines—and import that green energy back to Taiwan.
Taiwan News
+1

The types of green energy under consideration are solar, wind, and geothermal.
Taipei Times
+1

Motivation

Domestic resistance: local governments and residents often oppose new renewable-power infrastructure (plants, solar/wind farms) in Taiwan, which slows down projects.
Taiwan News
+2
Taipei Times
+2

Taiwan has pledged to reduce carbon emissions and reach net-zero by 2050. The demand for green power is rising, especially among manufacturers and industry.
Taipei Times
+3
Taipei Times
+3
Taiwan News
+3

There's a precedent: Singapore is planning to import electricity from Australia, which is much farther away. So, Taiwan sees building power plants in the Philippines (just ~300 km away) as plausible.
Taiwan News
+1

⚠️ Concerns & Pushback

Cost & Feasibility

Opposition legislators (from parties like the KMT and TPP) question how expensive this could be, especially the infrastructure needed, like undersea or submarine cables, power loss during transmission, etc.
Taiwan News
+1

For instance, an undersea cable from the Philippines to Taiwan may incur significant losses in transmission (one source notes up to 33% loss; others calculate potentially more depending on alternating current vs direct current lines).
Taiwan News
+1

Timing & Prematurity

Some argue that the proposal may be premature: at this stage, Taiwan doesn't yet have a detailed plan or study finalized. Minister Kuo acknowledged this and promised a feasibility study within five months.
Taiwan News
+1

Concerns that pushing for imported green energy might distract from improving local renewable installations and infrastructure (solar, wind etc.), which are behind schedule.
Taipei Times
+1

Energy Losses & Technical Challenges

Undersea cables lose power over long distances. The form of transmission (AC vs DC) matters.
Taiwan News
+1

There are questions about who builds such overseas plants (state vs private sector), who pays, how to ensure reliability, and what happens in times of geopolitical or climate risk.
Taipei Times
+1

Political / Ethical Questions

Some opposition voices worry that establishing power plants abroad could raise issues of environmental justice for host countries. Also, there are concerns about transparency, costs, and whether this shifts burden away from domestic responsibilities.
Taiwan News

🔍 Implications & What Taiwan Needs to Do

Feasibility Studies & Engineering Work: Taiwan needs solid work on cost, transmission loss, reliability, and environmental impacts.
Taiwan News
+1

Infrastructure Development: For example undersea/submarine power cables, or other delivery mechanisms for power imports. These require big capital, technology, and regulatory alignment.
Taipei Times
+1

Domestic vs Foreign Trade-Offs: Balancing building more green plants within Taiwan (overcoming local resistance) vs outsourcing vs import dependency.

Policy & Regulatory Clarity: Legislation or regulations to govern foreign green power sourcing, contracts, pricing, environmental regulation overseas, import rules.

Risk Management: Geopolitical risks, energy security (if imported power is disrupted), and ensuring the costs are not higher long-term.

If you want, I can get you the full transcript of that News at 14:00 piece, or do a deep-dive on what experts are saying about whether this plan makes sense (from engineering, economics, environmental standpoints). Do you prefer that?

Recent Taiwan green energy / policy news
reuters.com
How Taiwan's green power deficit threatens tech industry's bid for net zero
Jun 5, 2024
ft.com
Chipmaker TSMC hit by Taiwan's soaring energy prices and growing outages
Nov 5, 2024
reuters.com
Taiwan's offshore wind projects to move to deeper waters, requiring more state support
2 days ago

Didn't find what you were looking for? Search Below