Indian and Russian Social Media Roasts Trudeau | Vantage with Palki Sharma

Started by 457silky, Oct 18, 2024, 04:52 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.


tagninopso

Here's a breakdown of what the Firstpost segment Vantage with Palki Sharma covered in "Brokenist? Trudeau's Blunder Triggers Roast Session" plus related context on how Indian/Russian social media have been reacting to Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau. If you like, I can also pull up full transcripts or direct quotes.

🔍 What Happened in the Show

The piece centers on a gaffe by Justin Trudeau: he used the term "brokenist vision" instead of "broken vision" when criticizing his opponent's plan for the country.
Firstpost

The mistake quickly became fodder for jokes in Parliament and on social media, with people mocking and spoofing the phrase "brokenist" instead of "broken."
Firstpost

Palki Sharma uses this incident as a "Joke of the Day," highlighting how political speech errors can become viral moments.
Firstpost

🌐 How Indian (And Russian) Social Media Seem to Be Responding

From the coverage (and related discussions), you can infer several patterns:

Mockery Over Mistakes
Indian social media tends to seize upon verbal slip-ups like this, and they're often transformed into memes, GIFs, or comedic shares. The "brokenist" phrase is an example: people pick it up and mock it as evidence of carelessness or poor public speaking. (This is exactly what happened here.)
Firstpost

Political Framing
Such slips are used to discredit or diminish political opponents. The commentary is often less about the content of what was said and more about the competence or image of the speaker. Palki Sharma's segment frames Trudeau's error as a moment that exposes political gaffes.
Firstpost

Amplification Through Media
Shows like Vantage amplify these moments, often giving them more reach. The mistake went from Parliament β†’ social media β†’ a news commentary video. That magnifies its impact in public perception.
Firstpost

Cross-border Reactions (Russia, etc.)
The "Russian" dimension is a bit more vague in the sources I checked. I did not find strong, confirmed examples in Firstpost or in public reporting of Russian social media specifically roasting Trudeau over this "brokenist" error. The piece seems to be focused mostly on Canadian/Indian reactions. If there is Russian commentary, it wasn't highlighted in the article I saw.

Narrative Building
These roast sessions often feed into larger narratives: of Trudeau being out of touch, of leaders being gaffe-prone, or of political rivals using slip-ups to score points. The social media roast becomes more than humorβ€”it becomes political ammunition.
Firstpost

If you want, I can pull together current social media posts (tweets, Russian Telegram/ VK / whatever) so we can see examples of this roast in action (both in India and Russia) and how people there are interpreting it. Do you want that?

I prefer this response
ChatGPT
Response 2

Here's a summary of what I found on both topics:

1. Michigan Animal Rescue in Urgent Need of Donations After Social Media Fiasco

The rescue is the Animal Welfare Society of Southeastern Michigan, in Madison Heights, Michigan.
CBS News

Their Facebook page (30,000 followers) was suddenly shut down by the social media platform (Facebook) on allegations of spam.
CBS News

This was a major blow because the page was their key channel for exposure: for pleas for donations (monetary), supplies (food, toys, linens), and for finding homes for animals.
CBS News

As a result of losing that platform access, their donation flow dropped, and they are now struggling financially. They estimate they need at least US$15,000 in monetary donations to cover vet bills, supplies, and keep operations going.
CBS News

They have created a new Facebook page and are trying to migrate/fuse their old followers, but that takes time and hasn't fully restored their capacity.
CBS News

What you can do if you want to help:

Donate money directly (contact info given in articles).
CBS News

Donate supplies (food, linens, toys).
CBS News

Spread awareness (share their new page, share the story).
CBS News

2. "Indian and Russian Social Media Roasts Trudeau | Vantage with Palki Sharma"

I couldn't find a direct article or segment exactly matching the title "Indian and Russian Social Media Roasts Trudeau | Vantage with Palki Sharma". But I found something similar:

There is an episode titled "Brokenist? Trudeau's Blunder Triggers Roast Session | Vantage with Palki Sharma". In it, Trudeau (Canada's Prime Minister) accidentally used the word "brokenist" instead of "broken" when describing the opposition leader's vision.
Firstpost

That mistake led to him being widely mocked on social media. Laughing, memes, etc. The report describes it as a "roast session" in Parliament and then how people online picked up on it.
Firstpost

The Vantage segment ("Joke of the Day") highlights how such gaffes are seized upon both in Indian media / internet circles, but I did not find a credible source confirming that specifically Russians joined in roasting Trudeau in that episode. The source I found seems to focus more on India's take.
Firstpost

If you want, I can try to track down whether there is a version of the Vantage episode that covers both Indian and Russian responses, or get you a transcript of the roast comments from both countries. Do you want me to dig that up?


Didn't find what you were looking for? Search Below